Articles · Cooking
Why smoke point matters (and what it can't tell you)
What happens when a pan starts to smoke, why that haze is worth avoiding, and four habits that keep frying oil, and the air in your kitchen, cleaner.
· 6 min read
You've probably seen it: you turn away for a moment, and a thin blue haze rises from the pan. Maybe the smoke alarm joins in. You open the window, wave a tea towel and carry on cooking. But what just happened to the oil, and does it matter for the dinner or for you?
What is a smoke point?
An oil's smoke point is the temperature at which it starts to give off a steady stream of visible smoke. Below it, oil changes slowly. Above it, it breaks down quickly: its fats split, the pieces react with oxygen, and some of them escape into the air as smoke.
Different oils smoke at different temperatures. Refined oils, with more of the small, easily burnt parts removed, usually smoke later than unrefined ones. And the same oil smokes earlier every time it's reused, because the breakdown builds up.
Think about it: When did your pan last smoke? Was the oil new, or had it been used before?
Why is smoke worth avoiding?
The smoke itself tells you the oil has gone past the point where it copes well. Three things are happening:
- The oil is breaking down. Its fats split apart, and some of the pieces, mostly from polyunsaturated fats, form acrolein, the sharp, eye-stinging part of the smoke.
- Reactive compounds build up. Aldehydes and other products of oxidation form in the oil and in the air above it, more so in oils rich in polyunsaturated fat.
- You breathe some of it in. The International Agency for Research on Cancer lists the fumes from frying at high temperatures as "probably carcinogenic to humans". The strongest evidence comes from cooks frying in woks for years in poorly ventilated kitchens, not from the occasional smoky pan, but it's a good reason to keep the air moving.
The food suffers too: burnt oil tastes bitter and acrid, and it soaks into whatever you're cooking.
What the smoke point can't tell you
If a high smoke point were all that mattered, the "best" oil would simply be the one that smokes last. It isn't quite that simple.
The smoke point mostly reflects how many free fatty acids an oil contains, and it's judged by eye, so it's a rough guide at best. What it doesn't measure is how easily the oil's fats react with oxygen before it ever smokes. In one lab comparison of sunflower, corn and sesame oils and blends of them, sunflower oil had the highest smoke point, yet it was the least stable when heated.
Oils rich in monounsaturated fat, such as olive, rapeseed and high-oleic sunflower oil, change more slowly than oils rich in polyunsaturated fat, such as regular sunflower, corn and soybean oil. In one frying test, regular sunflower oil reached the usual limit for broken-down oil after about 9 fryings; high-oleic sunflower oil lasted about twice as long. Extra virgin olive oil also carries natural antioxidants, which is why it holds up well in long frying tests even though several seed oils smoke at higher temperatures.
So think of the smoke point as a warning line, not a score: stay under it, and pick oils that are stable as well.
Interior of a Kitchen, Martin Drolling, 1815, Musée du Louvre, Paris. A Paris kitchen two hundred years ago. Kitchens then had a hearth and a chimney to carry smoke away; ours have an extractor fan and a window, and both are worth using. Public domain · Wikimedia CommonsFour habits for cleaner frying
- Match the oil to the heat. For gentle frying, any good cooking oil works. For searing and stir-frying, use a refined oil with a high smoke point, such as refined rapeseed, peanut or avocado oil. Our article Which oil should you fry with? has a simple guide.
- Watch the pan, not the clock. Oil is ready when it shimmers and flows easily. Steady smoke means too hot: take the pan off the heat, let it cool, and start again with fresh oil if it smells burnt.
- Let the air move. Switch on the extractor fan before you start, and open a window if you can, especially when frying at high heat or for a long time.
- Don't reuse oil endlessly. Strain and store it cool and dark, and throw it away once it darkens, foams, smells sharp or starts smoking at a lower heat. Most European countries make restaurants throw frying oil away once about a quarter of it has broken down.
Try this: Keep an old jam jar by the cooker for used oil. Once it's cool and full, close it and put it in the bin; oil poured down the sink clogs the drains.
Think about it: Does your kitchen fan really go to the outside, or does it just blow the air back into the room? It's worth checking: a fan that vents outdoors clears smoke far better.
Quick quiz
Why does reused oil start smoking at a lower temperature?
Each heating breaks some of the oil down, and the broken-down parts smoke more easily. The more an oil has been used, the earlier it smokes.
If one oil has a higher smoke point than another, is it always more stable in the pan?
No. How easily its fats react with oxygen matters too. Olive and rapeseed oils, rich in monounsaturated fat, are quite stable even though some seed oils smoke later.
What's the single easiest way to breathe in less cooking smoke?
Turn on an extractor fan that vents outdoors, or open a window, whenever you fry.
Sources
- International Agency for Research on Cancer. Household use of solid fuels and high-temperature frying, IARC Monographs volume 95, 2010.
- Ewert A, Granvogl M, Schieberle P. Isotope-labeling studies on the formation pathway of acrolein during heat processing of oils. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2014.
- Ramroudi F, et al. Investigation of the physicochemical properties of vegetable oils blended with sesame oil and their oxidative stability during frying. International Journal of Food Science, 2022.
- Holgado F, et al. Performance of olive-pomace oils in discontinuous and continuous frying: comparative behavior with sunflower oils and high-oleic sunflower oils. Foods, 2021.
- Sánchez-Muniz FJ, Bastida S. Frying oil discarding: polar content vs. oligomer content determinations. Forum of Nutrition, 2003.
- Moumtaz S, et al. Toxic aldehyde generation in and food uptake from culinary oils during frying practices. Scientific Reports, 2019.
General information, not medical advice. If you have a health condition, are pregnant or take medication, ask a doctor or dietitian what is right for you.